Discover 37 Best Italian Restaurants Sydney Has in 2025

Are you craving a taste of Italy without leaving Sydney? Whether it’s the aroma of freshly baked pizza al forno, the creamy indulgence of risotto alla milanese, or the satisfying twirl of perfectly cooked spaghetti carbonara, “YES real carbonara”, Our Sydney’s Italian restaurants over deliver authentic flavors that transport your taste buds from Sydney to Milan or Sicily in the south of Italy.

The vibrant Italian dining scene is huge in Sydney, with the finest chefs spending weeks crafting your favourite dishes with passion, tradition, and premium Tuscan ingredients like Prosciutto di Parma, Mozzarella di Bufala, and fresh Pasta Fatta in Casa. From cozy trattorias serving comforting bowls of gnocchi to stylish fine dining italian ristorantes offering elevated plates of ossobuco and tagliatelle al ragù, the options are endless.

What about exploring waterfront venues perfect for the best dinner date night, or find hidden gems serving gelato that rivals Rome’s finest. If you’re on the hunt for the best Italian Sydney has to offer, this guide will unveil must-visit spots where antipasti sets the tone, secondi piatti impress, and decadent tiramisu leaves you craving more.

Whether you’re a local or visiting, these Italian restaurants in Sydney promise a journey of flavors you won’t forget!

Discover More Of The Best:
Best Pizza Restaurants in Sydney
Best Pasta Restaurants in Sydney
Best Seafood Restaurants in Sydney
Best Steak Restaurants in Sydney
Best Dessert Restaurants in Sydney

So Lets Dive Into The Top Italian Restaurants in Sydney

Figo Restaurant & Bar

Figo is the perfect blend of elegance and authenticity with an atmosphere that is dimly lit, intimate yet lively, with soft lighting and attentive staff who make you feel like family.

Start with their Figo Tatare Di Tonno, a vibrant tuna tartare bursting with fresh, zesty flavors. Their truffled pasta is a perfectly balanced and aromatic experience. For seafood lovers, the tender, chargrilled octopus is a must-try. End your meal with their Classic Tiramisu, paired with creamy white chocolate ice cream — a dessert worth savoring.

Figo Italian Restaurant Bar

Divino Osteria

Step into Divino Osteria, where the charm of Italian dining comes alive.

The menu is a celebration of refined flavours, starting with freshly shucked oysters that bring the taste of the sea, and Burrata paired with smoked eggplant purée, a perfect blend of creamy and smoky flavours. The Spatchcock Alla Diavola offers us a mouthwatering bird with a fiery kick, while the Selezione Di Formaggi is a curated indulgence of fine Italian cheeses.

The ambiance is intimate yet inviting, with soft lighting and rustic decor that transports you to a cozy trattoria. Perfect for savoring unforgettable moments.

Divino Osteria - Sydney Italian Cuisine

Osteria Coogee

Osteria Coogee is a culinary treat, blending coastal charm with Italian sophistication. Their Weekend Bottomless Lunches are a must-try—think free-flowing drinks paired with a thoughtfully curated menu.

Start with the creamy Polenta with Truffle Aioli, savor the freshness of Tuna Tartare, and indulge in the succulent Porchetta with Seeded Mustard Gremolata—each dish an ode to authentic flavours. The atmosphere? Warm and inviting, with an understated elegance that feels like dining in a stylish Italian villa.

Perfect for leisurely weekends with loved ones, Osteria Coogee crafts not just meals but memories. It’s more than a meal; it’s an experience

Osteria Coogee

I Maccheroni

Stepping into I Maccheroni feels like visiting an old friend’s cozy Italian home, where food and warmth take center stage. The intimate ambiance, friendly chatter, and authentic flavors make every visit feel like a culinary hug.

We found starting with the mushroom arancini—crispy, golden perfection with a creamy, earthy filling that sets the tone for indulgence. The pork ribs in balsamic glaze are a revelation, tender and caramelized with just the right balance of sweetness and tang. For mains, the beef cheek ragout is a showstopper, slow-cooked to melt-in-your-mouth perfection over al dente pasta. Finish with the ricotta tiramisu, a dreamy, cloud-like dessert.

I Maccheroni Italian Restaurant

Gino’s Kitchen & Cocktails

Gino’s Kitchen & Cocktails is a delightful escape into the heart of Italian cuisine. Their menus is a delight with their bruschetta pomodoro. The quattro formaggi pizza is a cheesy masterpiece, perfect for sharing, but it’s hard to resist keeping it all to yourself. Everyone’s favourite, the spaghetti carbonara, is creamy and indulgent, a comforting classic done right. Don’t forget to check out their blackboard dessert special—it’s always a sweet surprise! If you’re in the mood for a lively afternoon, the Bottomless Brunch from 1 PM pairs perfectly with the warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit unforgettable.

ginos italian kitchen and cocktails

Olio Kensington Street

Olio Kensington Street brings the heart of Sicily to life with an unforgettable dining experience with an industrial feel to its restaurant. But dont be fooled as you can experience their house-made focaccia and olive oil or undulge in the delicate Hokkaido scallops paired with smoky chorizo, a match made no foodie would argue. For mains, the Agnello steals the show—succulent barbecued lamb rump complemented by smoked yogurt, velvety aubergine, dukkha, and a rich port wine jus. If you’re dropping by for lunch, dont miss the delightfully curated 3-Course Lunch. Set in a stylish yet inviting space, Olio offers a personal touch, making every bite as memorable as the atmosphere around you.

olio kensington street

Otto Ristorante Sydney

Found on the wharf-side terrace, Otto Ristorante Sydney offers an exceptional dining experience infused with the vibrant flavors of modern Italian cuisine. Led by Head Chef Richard Ptacnik, the menu is a celebration of refined dishes, from Sydney rock oysters Venetian to indulgent Woodside goat’s curd with truffle honey. Ptacnik’s saffron linguine or White Pyrenees lamb backstrap are also a local favourite. The stunning waterfront setting complements the elegant yet welcoming atmosphere, creating the perfect backdrop for a memorable meal. At Otto, every detail is designed to offer an unforgettable taste of Italy in Sydney’s heart.

otto ristorante sydney

Fratelli Paradiso

Fratelli Paradiso, an Italian trattoria in Sydney’s Potts Point, has been a culinary gem since opening in 2001 by brothers Giovanni and Enrico Paradiso. Known for its minimalist yet intimate ambiance, the restaurant features dark tones and a simple blackboard menu that exudes understated elegance.

Diners rave about signature dishes like the Carpaccio, a harmonious mix of raw beef, anchovy aioli, rocket, and parmesan. The Paccheri with veal ragu bianco is a pasta masterpiece, while dessert lovers can’t resist the baba al liquore with raspberries and crème diplomat. Fratelli Paradiso effortlessly blends authenticity with contemporary flair, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience.

fratelli paradiso

10 William Street

Tucked away in Paddington, 10 William Street is an intimate, two-storey bistro known for its cozy atmosphere and authentic Italian flavours. The blackboard menu showcases seasonal, hand-picked dishes that pair beautifully with an extensive European wine list.

Local favourites include the indulgent tiramisu and crispy fiori di zucca & caciocavallo fritti, perfect for starting your meal on a high note. Feeling adventurous? Try the regal red emperor, romesco & peppers for a bold and satisfying choice. With its warm ambiance and commitment to quality, 10 William Street offers an elevated yet approachable dining experience for lovers of great food and wine.

italian on 10 william st

Big Mama’s Trattoria

Big Mama’s Trattoria is a charming Italian family restaurant that brings the heart of Italy to your table. Known for its warm ambiance and welcoming service, it’s the perfect spot for a cozy meal with loved ones.

The menu boasts traditional Italian delights, including hearty Minestrone, creamy Burrata, flavorful Zuppa di Mare, and comforting Penne with Italian Meatballs. Pair your meal with one of their sweet Italian wines for an authentic dining experience. Big Mama’s Trattoria is a celebration of Italy’s rich culinary heritage, offering a true taste of tradition with every dish. Perfect for families, friends, or romantic evenings!

big mamas trattoria

Sienna Marina Restaurant & Bar

Sienna Marina Restaurant & Bar is a vibrant Italian eatery that transforms from a cozy café by day to a sophisticated restaurant by night. Serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner, Sienna Marina offers something for every craving.

By day, enjoy café favourites like the Black Angus Beef Burger, Fish Taco, and the intriguingly named Magic Mushrooms (yes, the legal kind!). As evening falls, savour Italian classics like the tender Braised Osso Buco or the flavorful Blue Swimmer Crab Penne. With an extensive dessert menu boasting 16 indulgent options, Sienna Marina promises a delightful dining experience from sunrise to sunset.

Louie

Louie Italian Coogee is a charming neighbourhood gem run by the passionate and welcoming Chris. This Italian eatery exudes warmth, offering a menu that’s both comforting and refined.

Discover your culinary journey with the Fritto Misto, a crispy mix of calamari, whitebait, and school prawns paired with saffron aioli. Indulge in the delicate Truffled Ricotta Agnolotti, complemented by earthy king oyster mushrooms and rich brown butter. For a hearty option, the Veal Schnitzel shines with its amatriciana sauce, parmigiano, pancetta, and sage. Louie Italian combines traditional flavours with a modern touch, making it a beloved dining destination in Coogee.

louie coogee